基于5E模型的活动效果 ——以十年级学生气体概念理解为例外文翻译资料

 2023-01-05 06:01

基于5E模型的活动效果

——以十年级学生气体概念理解为例

Mustafa Yadigaroglua,*, Gokhan Demircioglub

摘要: 这项研究的目的是调查十年级学生理解气体一般性能中用到的基于5E模式活动的效果。该项研究由土耳其Akcaabat州的一所高校在2010-2011学年提出。它运用了相类似的实验设计,用来挑选参与这项研究的40位10年级学生在两个教室中。并随机将其中一个教室作为实验组(13个男生,7个女生),另一个作为对照组(11个男生,9个女生)。实验里有16个多选题和4个开放性问题用来收集数据。它测试50个学生,他们的可靠性系数是0.78。在试验期间,对照组授课用传统的方式,而实验组授课用基于建构主义5E模式活动发展的方式。收集到的数据用独立样本T检测,发现了在实验组的喜好统计上最大的不同。教师设计建构主义学习环境用来培养他们的技能是必不可少的。为了达到这个目标,教师应该接受相应的训练。

Abstract The aim of this study is to investigate the effect of activities developed based on 5E model on grade 10 studentsrsquo; understanding of general properties of gases. The study was conducted in a high school in Akcaabat province of Trabzon, in 2010-2011 academic years. The study used the quasi-experimental design. 40 grade 10 students in two classes were selected for the study. While one of the classes was randomly assigned as experimental group (13 boys, 7 girls), the other was determined as control group (11 boys, 9 girls). In the study, Concept Achievement Test (CAT) including 16 multiple choice items and 4 open-ended questions was used to collect the data. The test was piloted with 50 students and its Reliability Coefficient was found 0,78. In during the treatment, the control group was taught by traditional approach and the experimental group was taught by using the activities developed based on 5E model of the constructivist approach. The collected data were compared by using the independent sample t test. A statistically significant difference in favor of experimental group was detected. It is essential that teachers should develop their skills for designing constructivist learning environment. With this aim, teachers should be given in-service training.

关键词: 化学教育;气体概念;建构主义学习途径;5E模式;

Keywords: Chemistry Education, Gas Concept, Constructivist Approach, 5E Model

一、概述

在选择教学模式时,教师寻求帮助学生全面理解新概念的策略。他们的目标是吸引学生,激励他们学习,并指导他们的技能发展。其中一种方法是结合基于探究的方法,比如基于主动学习的5E模型。

很多学生对于学习化学中包含抽象和不可视的概念有学习困难,比如原子和分子。这种情况下导致各个层次的学生发展出很多关于化学概念的替换概念。然而这项研究指出很多学生在没有理解概念的情况下完成化学课程。气体概念是大学化学课程最重要的概念之一,因为它是学习其他化学概念的基础。对于气体的调查指出学生会发展出很多替换概念,举个例子,一些学生认为气体没有重量,一些人相信在液体或者固体情况下,气体轻于其他同样大小的材料。

研究表明,促进学习的事件有一定的顺序,称为学习周期。教育家J. Myron Atkin和Robert Karplus在1962年提出,有效的学习周期包括三个关键要素:探索、学期介绍和概念应用。在他们的方案中,探索使学习者对手头的主题产生兴趣,提出问题,并找出对他们目前的理解不满意的地方。新概念和术语的介绍,主要由指导教师介绍,但由指导教师和学生双方协商,然后。最后,应用概念为学习者提供了机会在课堂应用他们的新想法,尝试他们在小说的新理解上下文,和评估的完整理解,“根据本文金伯利·d·坦纳“秩序问题:使用5 e模型,使教学与人们如何学习。

研究者在他们生活中遇到的很多事情都与化学有关。他们经常会发现各种气体,如发现二氧化碳和氧气并从中获得经验,了解这些物质。将生活中获得的经验和知识以及他们在学校新学习的知识联系起来,这对建立有意义并且永久的知识体系提供了基础。建构主义学者的学习观和相关理论在这一点上是有希望的,因为他们被教育工作者、科学老师、课程设计者广泛运用。学习者自己在先前知识体系里建立新的知识,并在这个过程中扮演积极的角色。对于这个观点建构主义理论是支持的。

在其他方面,新的知识是被学习者主动构建的,而不是被动的由环境或者老师传达给他们。这一理论在科学课堂上的实践应用之一是5E模式。这个模式包含五个步骤(引入。探索。解释。迁移。评价)这个模式可以激发学生好奇心,提升学生对于这门学科的期望并且可以让他们积极使用自己的知识和技能。

这项研究的目的是根据建构主义者对10年级学生学习的看法,确定与5E模式兼容的活动效果。

参与

在学习周期的第一阶段,教师的工作是了解学生的先验知识,并找出任何知识缺口。培养学生对新概念的兴趣也是很重要的,这样学生就可以随时准备学习。老师可能会要求学生提出开放性问题,或者写下他们已经知道的话题。这也是第一次向学生介绍这个概念。

探索

在探索阶段,学生通过具体的学习经历,积极探索新概念。他们可能会被要求通过科学的方法,并与他们的同龄人进行交流来进行观察。这个阶段允许学生以实际操作的方式学习。

解释

这是一个由教师主导的阶段,帮助学生综合新知识,并在他们需要进一步澄清时提出问题。根据《5E教学模式:探究性科学教学的学习周期方法》,为了使解释阶段有效,教师应该在更直接地介绍技术信息之前,要求学生分享他们在探究阶段学到的知识。这也是教师利用视频、计算机软件或其他辅助工具来增进理解的时候。

精加工

5E模型的精化阶段主要是为学生提供应用所学知识的空间。这有助于他们加深理解。教师可以要求学生制作报告或进行额外的调查,以加强新技能。这个阶段允许学生在评估前巩固他们的知识。

评估

5E模型允许正式和非正式评估。在这个阶段,教师可以观察学生,看他们是否完全掌握了核心概念。注意学生是否根据所学以不同的方式处理问题也很有帮助。评估阶段的其他有用元素包括自我评估、同行评估、写作作业和考试。

二、方法

本研究是在土耳其Akcaabat省的一所高中进行的。一位拥有15年工作经验的化学教师,他有两个10年级的班级包括40个学生参加这次研究。这两个班级被随机分成对照组和实验组。在实验组里有20位学生(13个男孩,7个女孩)对照组有20位学生(11位男生,9位女生)。实验组的学生采用基于5E模式的活动进行教学,而对照组的学生则采用传统的方法(以教师为中心)进行教学。

(一)数据收集工具

在研究中,概念成就测验(CAT)包含了20个问题,其中16个多选,4个开放式问题,被用作测试前和测试后,以决定学生对气体概念的理解。概念成就测试中的项目是由研究人员开发的。学生对于开放性的问题的回答被归类为正确和错误。多选题和开放式题型都同样的分值,答对一题得5分,答错一题得-分。总分100分。概念成就测验与50名学生进行了试点,Cronbach 可靠性洗漱测验的结果为0.78。在这项研究中概念成就测验被用于测验气体一般性质的前和测验后实验

(二)材料的开发

在文学中,建构主义理论有很多教学模式,比如3E,4E,5E,7E。在当前这项研究中,运用了建构主义理论中很受欢迎的5E模式。贝比对于其中五个步骤进行了解释。作者结合“气体”单元的学习目标,开展了四项5E学习活动。他们分别是:“温度对气体溶解度的影响”“气体的压强”“分子重量对传播速度的影响”以及“温度对气体压强的影响”。其中已开发的活动之一“温度对气体溶解度的影响”在表中说明了:

1.在进行每一项活动之前,学生们被分成了4个实验小组,每个项目由5名学生和每项活动所需的所有材料组成。

表一 基于5E模式发展的活动实例

在这一步,老师对学生提出问题以此引出他们的先前已有的认知。

像可乐和苏打等酸性饮料我们推测日常生活中应该冰饮,为什么?

我们为什么要在水族箱中加入冷水?

让学生回答并思考他们所认为的可能的结果。

在这一步,小组中的五位学生进行合作,实验材料:两瓶苏打水,一块冰,热水,和开瓶器。这些实验材料分配给小组,之后由他们给出一个实验程序解释步骤。每个小组都由自己主动动手,写下他们的观察结果,并经过对结果的讨论得出一个相近的结论

在这一步中,小组向整个班级展示他们的结果。展示之后,老师开始通过对每个小组结果的提问来让全班展开讨论。并且老师通过运用日常生活中的例子和问题来支撑讨论。以此得出一个共同的结论

当潜水员在潜水后突然发现,他们可能得了减压病(DCI),因为他们血液中的氮气耗尽

通过这个问题,学生被要求刚刚学习的新知识应用到新的环境中。

在这一步,需要明确的问题是学生是否学会掌握了新知识。

“在你看来,在炎热的夏天,为什么鱼要洗”

引入

探究

解释

迁移

评价

三、结果和讨论

在进行测试前,对预测试的数据进行了评估,并与独立样本T检测进行比较。如表2所示,实验组(=37.44;SD=8.51)对照组(=40.45;SD=9.06)的T实验结果(T(38)=1.04;Pgt;0.05)比较两者并没有显著的差异。由于组间没有差异,因此也将后测试与T测试进行了比较。

表2 实验组和对照组测验前后T检测结果

测试

组别

N

Mean

S.D

df

t

p

前测试

实验组

20

37,55

8,51

38

1,04

0,304

20

40,45

9,06

后测试

对照组

20

78,8

8,63

38

剩余内容已隐藏,支付完成后下载完整资料


Available online at www.sciencedirect.com

Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 47 (2012) 634 – 637

CY-ICER 2012

understanding of the gas concept

Mustafa Yadigaroglua,*, Gokhan Demircioglub

a.b. Karadeniz Technical University, Fatih Faculty of Education, Trabzon, 61335, Turkey

Abstract

The aim of this study is to investigate the effect of activities developed based on 5E model on grade 10 studentsrsquo; understanding of general properties of gases. The study was conducted in a high school in Akcaabat province of Trabzon, in 2010-2011 academic years. The study used the quasi-experimental design. 40 grade 10 students in two classes were selected for the study. While one of the classes was randomly assigned as experimental group (13 boys, 7 girls), the other was determined as control group (11 boys, 9 girls). In the study, Concept Achievement Test (CAT) including 16 multiple choice items and 4 open-ended questions was used to collect the data. The test was piloted with 50 students and its Reliability Coefficient was found 0,78. In during the treatment, the control group was taught by traditional approach and the experimental group was taught by using the activities developed based on 5E model of the constructivist approach. The collected data were compared by using the independent sample t test. A statistically significant difference in favor of experimental group was detected. It is essential that teachers should develop their skills for designing constructivist learning environment. With this aim, teachers should be given in-service training.

copy; 20122011Publishedby byElsevierElsevierLtd. LtdSelection. and/or peer review under responsibility of Prof. Dr. Huuml;seyin Uzunboylu

Keywords: Chemistry Education, Gas Concept, Constructivist Approach, 5E Model

1. Introduction

When choosing an instructional model, teachers seek strategies that help students gain a complete understanding of new concepts. They aim to engage students, motivate them to learn, and guide them toward skill development. One of the ways to do that is by incorporating inquiry-based approaches like the 5E Model, which is grounded in active learning.

Research suggests that there is a set order of events that facilitates learning, known as a learning cycle. Educators J. Myron Atkin and Robert Karplus argued in 1962 that effective learning cycles involve three key elements: exploration, term introduction, and concept application. “In their scheme, exploration allowed the learners to become interested in the subject at hand, raise questions, and identify points of dissatisfaction with their current understanding. Introduction of new ideas and terms, primarily by the instructor, but negotiated by both instructor and students, followed. Finally, concept application provided learners with opportunities within the classroom to apply their new ideas, try out their new understandings in novel contexts, and evaluate the completeness of their understanding,” according to Kimberly D. Tanner in the article “Order Matters: Using the 5E Model to Align Teaching With How People Learn.”

Most students have difficulty learning chemistry which contains abstract and invisible concepts, such as atom and molecule. This situation causes students at all levels to develop plenty of alternative conceptions concerning

chemistry concepts (Bar et al., 1991; Demircio Griffiths et al., 1992). However, the research indicates that many students achieve the chemistry courses without the conceptual understandings of the concepts (Nakhleh amp; Krajcik, 1994). The gas concept is one of the most important concepts in undergraduate chemistry curriculum because it is essential to learn other chemistry concepts. Research on gases showed that students developed a large

number of alternative conceptions (Benson et al., 1993; Birinci-Konur amp; Ayas, 2010; 2009; For example, some students think that gas has no weight and some believes that gas is lighter than the same material in its liquid or solid state (Stavy, 1988).

Many events that learners encounter in their daily lives are related to Chemistry. For example, they frequently come across variety of gases, such as carbon dioxide and oxygen and gain experience and knowledge about them. Connecting associate new information they learn at the school with the gained experience and knowledge in the daily

lives provides a basis for establishing meaningful and permanent learning (Zan- 2008). The constructivist view of learning and similar theories (e.g. context-based learning) is promising at this point because they are widely adopted by educators, science teachers and curriculum designers. The constructive learning approach supported the claim that learner individually build new knowledge upon previous knowledge and has an active role in this process. On the other word, new knowledge is actively constructed by the learner, not passively transmitted from the environment or teacher (von Glasersfeld, 1995). One of practice applications of this theory in science classroom is 5E model (Keser, 2003). The model consists of the steps (engage, explore, explain, elaborate and evaluation) which

actively use their knowledge and skills (Ergin, 2006).

The aim of this study is to determine the effect of the activities developed as compatible with 5E model based on the constructivist view of learning on grade 10 students understanding of the general properties of gases.

ENGAGE

In the first phase of the learning cycle, the teacher works to gain an understanding of the studentsrsquo; prior knowledge and identify any knowledge gaps. It is also important to foster an interest in the upcoming concepts so students will be ready to learn. Teachers might task students with asking opening qu

剩余内容已隐藏,支付完成后下载完整资料


资料编号:[277991],资料为PDF文档或Word文档,PDF文档可免费转换为Word

您需要先支付 30元 才能查看全部内容!立即支付

课题毕业论文、文献综述、任务书、外文翻译、程序设计、图纸设计等资料可联系客服协助查找。